| CHARACTERS | | | |
| J.M. Barrie | | Brenton Ferrell | Todd LeeMaster |
| Mary | | Avery Dall-Hilton | Avery Gleason |
| Sylvia | | Laura Frisby | Lisa Prina |
| Mrs. Du Maurier | | Kelli Brown | Tara Jean Harris |
| Frohman/Hook | | Christopher Fosse | Dane Robertson |
| George | | Noah Parson | |
| Peter | | Miles Robertson | |
| Jack | | Tanner Johnson | |
| Michael/Prologue Characters | | Max Chase | |
| Elliot | Stage Manager | Conrad Johnson | |
| Cannan/Smee | | David Jessop | |
| | | |
| SERVANTS | | | |
| Albert | Servant | Kent Dodds | |
| Emily | Servant | Christy Graves | |
| Thomas | Servant | Sam Cole | |
| Lael | Servant | Kaitlyn Felix | |
| | | |
| ACTORS | | | |
| Miriam/”Wendy” | Costume Mistress | Bridgette Madsen | |
| Henshaw/”Nana” | | Isaac Widdison | |
| Bassett/”Mermaid” | | Brooke Jorden | |
| Cromer/”Michael” | | Jesse Marchant | |
| Jones/”Mermaid” | | Vonnie Hilton | |
| Turpin/”Hook” | | Brett Rasmussen | |
| Potter/”Peter Pan” | | Ashley Jackman | |
| | | |
| ENSEMBLE | | | |
| Ice Cream Man | | Eran Gonzalez | |
| Nanny | | Alli Knutson | |
| Policeman | | Ray LeBaron | |
| Park Keeper | | Sam Hunt | |
| School Marm | | Lindsey Greer | |
| | | |
| Prologue Characters/Park-goers/Orphans | | | |
| Charli | Bohls | | |
| Isla | Brown | | |
| Pauline | Buttrey | | |
| Kate | Clyde | | |
| Max | Dominguez | | |
| Mercury | Fosse | | |
| Aeliana | Harris | | |
| Aurelia | Harris | | |
| Wren | Jackson | | |
| Mia | Jensen | | |
| Madi | Jorden | | |
| Maximus | Mahajan | | |
| Kayin | Mathews | | |
| Lucy | Peacock | | |
| Sylvie | Reynolds | | |
| Talia | Shoell | | |
| Mae | Soha | | |
| Claire | Tietjen | | |
| Erika | Wessman | | |
| | | |
| Park-goers/Lost Boys/Indians/Players | | | |
| Anna | Brown | | |
| Rebecca | Dodds | | |
| Benson | Doty | | |
| Cameron | Doty | | |
| Persephone | Fosse | | |
| Molly | Garrett | | |
| Sienna | Halladay | | |
| Izzie (Elizabeth) | Jackson | | |
| Kira | Jensen | | |
| Elena | Judd | | |
| Georgia | Lindsay | | |
| Miraya | Mahajan | | |
| Ainsley | Miller | | |
| Aayla | Powell | | |
| Emerson | Reynolds | | |
| Raina | Rhoton | | |
| Bree | Russon | | |
| Zoe | Russon | | |
| Alli | Wood | | |
| | | |
| Park-goers/Pirates/Acting Troupe | | | |
| WOMEN- *Starred Names are also Troupe Couple Dancers | | | |
| McKenzie | Alder | | |
| Kezia | Burrows* | | |
| Kaitlyn | Felix* | | |
| Christy | Graves* | | |
| Lindsey | Greer | | |
| Abby | Henry* | | |
| Ivonne | Hilton* | | |
| Ashley | Jackman* | | |
| Brooke | Jorden* | | |
| Alli | Knutson | | |
| Alyssa | Knutti* | | |
| Bridgette | Madsen* | | |
| Benny | Shipp | | |
| Kayla | Titus | | |
| MEN- Also Troupe Couple Dancers | | | |
| Samuel | Cole | | |
| Kent | Dodds | | |
| Eran | Gonzalez | | |
| Sam | Hunt | | |
| David | Jessop | | |
| Conrad | Johnson | | |
| Ray | LeBaron | | |
| Jessie | Marchant | | |
| Isaac | Widdison | | |
| | | |